Named and Shamed: Judging the Judges (November 2021)

April 17th – A belated note from April, courtesy of Thomas Hauser (writing for The Sweet Science):

The Hauser Report: Some Thoughts on Boxing

The New Hampshire State Athletic Commission allowed a whopping ten boxers on a national Association of Boxing Commissions ‘watch list’ for “fighters who have long losing streaks and multiple defeats by knockout and presumably shouldn’t be fighting anymore” to fight on the same card. Obviously, they all lost.

Dangerous, to say the least.

 

November 5th – Maiva Hamadouche never had a chance against golden girl Mikaela Mayer, did she?

In a very close fight, not only did the scorecards read Tim Cheatham 98-92, Max DeLuca 99-91 and Lisa Giampa 100-90 (criminal), but after round 9, ref Mike Ortega threatened to stop the fight.

It was frankly insulting, both to Hamadouche and the intelligence of any viewer.

 

November 6th – In one of the bouts on Sky Sports’ return to the Prizefighter one night tournament format, Tom Farrell clearly won the first round against Kane Gardner.

Combined with a knockdown in the third, that should have meant a unanimous win. Mark Lyson somehow saw things 28-28, but was thankfully overruled by the other judges.

 

Canelo Alvarez stopped Caleb Plant in the 11th round to claim undisputed 168lb. supremacy.

In truth, it was a fight he controlled all the way, which makes Patricia Morse Jarman’s 96-94 card nonsense.

 

November 13th – Time for some praise for a change.

Mark Lyson performed admirably in the Terri Harper-Alycia Baumgardner fight, jumping in at the perfect time to stop the fight in round 4 with Harper suddenly out on her feet.

 

November 19th – Prospect Khalil Coe was lucky to avoid defeat, drawing with Aaron Casper. Eddie Scuncio’s 39-37 card for Coe was pure A-side BS.

 

November 20th – Premature stoppage by Alan Abeles in round 2 of the Istvan Bernath-Deon Hale heavyweight bout.

(Amusing) Footage by way of Tim Boxeo:

 

November 26th – Erika Cruz Hernandez comfortably outfought Melissa Esquivel to defend her women’s featherweight title, only for it to be scored a split decision thanks to Pablo Gaeta (97-93).

 

November 27th – Premature stoppage from ref Ricky Gonzalez in round 2 of Anthony Herrera’s win over fellow debutant Jonathan Tejeda.

 

The Kali Reis-Jessica Camara fight could have been scored either way, but the 97-93 cards in favour of Reis from Tom Schreck and Martha Tremblay did not reflect reality.

 

George Kambosos shocked the world by beating Teofimo Lopez, thankfully receiving a just split decision verdict.

However, it should be noted that Don Trella (who scored the fight for Lopez by one point by virtue of this) and Glenn Feldman gave the 12th round to Lopez, a stanza which was dominated by the Australian challenger.

 

Pound4poundireland Scorecards from December 2021

George Arias 97-94 Cassius Chaney, officially SD

Jerry Forrest 96-94 Michael Hunter (rematch), officially a DRAW

Devin Haney 116-112 Joseph Diaz, officially UD

Katie Taylor 97-92 Firuza Sharipova, officially UD

Joe Cordina 100-90 Miko Khatchatryan, officially UD

Vasyl Lomachenko 119-108 Richard Commey, officially UD

Lerrone Richards 116-112 Carlos Gongora, officially SD

Zelfa Barrett 120-107 Bruno Tarimo, officially UD

Joseph Parker 120-105 Dereck Chisora (rematch), officially UD

Marlen Esparza 99-89 Anabel Ortiz, officially UD

Lamont Roach 97-93 Rene Alvarado, officially UD

Gervonta Davis 117-111 Isaac Cruz, officially UD

Pound4poundireland Scorecards from November 2021

Mikaela Mayer 96-94 Maiva Hamadouche, officially UD

George Kambosos 114-112 Teofimo Lopez, officially SD

Erika Cruz 97-93 Melissa Esquivel, officially SD

Kenichi Ogawa 116-109 Azinga Fuzile, officially UD

Matteo Signani 117-111 Ruben Diaz, officially UD

Jaime Munguia 117-111 Gabriel Rosado, officially UD

D’Mitrius Ballard 98-92 Paul Valenzuela Jr., officially UD

Jessica Camara 96-95 Kali Reis, officially Reis by SD

Murodjon Akhmadaliev 119-109 Jose Velasquez, officially UD

Stephen Fulton 114-114 Brandon Figueroa, officially Fulton by MD

December 29th’s Random Boxing Rants

A true alpha male, Terence Crawford dominates the room (with a rapt audience featuring Regis Prograis, Jean Pascal and Lee McGregor):

https://tinyurl.com/5a427jv5

 

Sign me up for Seniesa Estrada-Marlen Esparza II in 2022.

 

ICYMI, Corey Erdman explores the tortured headspace of Teofimo Lopez going into his fight with George Kambosos:

https://www.boxingscene.com/teofimo-lopez-prophecy-crashes-george-kambosos-catapults-his-stock–162373

 

David Diamante’s fight starts now, and all our thoughts are with him:

https://www.si.com/boxing/2021/12/27/boxing-ring-announcer-david-diamante-motorcycle-accident

 

The WBA regular heavyweight title picture never ceases to amaze. 

In case anyone needs a reminder of the epic farce that unfolded on January 29th of this year (the latest part of a ridiculous saga that stretches all the way back to a Ruslan Chagaev-Fres Oquendo Chechnya fight in 2014 that was mired in controversy), Thomas Hauser can fill you in:

Don King – 2 Samuel 1:19, 1:25, 1:27 “How are the Mighty Fallen”

In short, Manny Charr was stripped of the belt for no apparent reason and Trevor Bryan stopped an ancient/obese Bermane Stiverne to fill the vacancy at short notice.

Incredibly, Hauser writes that there were just 51 pre-orders on Fite TV for the pay per view, of which I was one, and less than 300 buys overall.

Charr was supposed to fight Bryan within 120 days, but, to nobody’s surprise, it has taken the WBA until now to order that the fight take place.

Don King once again won the promotional rights at purse bids. The fight is again set for one month from today, one year exactly from last year’s scheduled bout that never materialized.

But does anyone believe it will actually happen?

One clue that it won’t is that Charr was set to be announced as the opponent for Joe Joyce’s next bout, until Joyce damaged his wrist in training.

A further subplot is that Daniel Dubois, who not long ago was stopped by Joyce, looms as a mandatory of sorts for the beltholder. Of course, Oleksandr Usyk holds the full WBA title after his win over Anthony Joshua.

That isn’t the end of the story of this card, however.

In the co-feature, Ilunga Makabu is set for a mandatory defence of his cruiserweight title versus Thabiso Mchunu, whom he previously defeated in 2015.

If we’re to believe what Canelo and Eddy Reynoso have been saying, this could decide the next opponent for boxing’s biggest star and pound for pound king.

Only in America…

 

More from Thomas Hauser, this time on the Oscar Valdez drug test failure and the wider problems this highlights:

The Hauser Report: Oscar Valdez, Phentermine, and the Larger Issue

 

 

“Casuals” is a funny term, in that it went from a term of disdain coined by the hardcore boxing following for those who do not follow the sport closely, to a mainstream coinage freely used by promoters and TV execs.

Tom Kershaw for the Independent: “Donald Curry’s longest fight”

https://www.independent.co.uk/sport/boxing/donald-curry-longest-fight-cte-b1971364.html

Donald Curry was once considered the best boxer in the world, but for the last two decades, the toll of his career has steadily caused his life to unravel. Tom Kershaw speaks to his family; friends; former trainer; protege; doctors; and officials to uncover how one of the sport’s all-time greats slipped through the cracks

Pound4poundireland’s December 22nd POUND FOR POUND top 10

1. Saul ‘Canelo’ Alvarez

2. Oleksandr Usyk

3. Naoya Inoue

4. Juan Francisco Estrada

5. Josh Taylor

6. Terence Crawford

7. Tyson Fury

8. Vasyl Lomachenko

9. Errol Spence

10. Kazuto Ioka

  • Time for a belated update: George Kambosos knocks #8 Teofimo Lopez, 2020’s Fighter of the Year, out of the lightweight throne and out of the pound for pound list in the year’s most stunning upset.
  • Vasyl Lomachenko rises one place, over Errol Spence, after a good win over Richard Commey.
  • Consideration was given to Kambosos, Roman Gonzalez and Artur Beterbiev (good win recently over Marcus Browne) for the number 10 spot.
  • However, I’ve chosen 4 weight titlist Kazuto Ioka, who ended 2020 in the same spot. He fights to defend his position on New Year’s Eve.